MI2N
Music Industry News Network
SUNDAY, APRIL 26TH
Advanced Search
MusicDish Advertising Network
Subscribe to Mi2N's Free Newsletters B2N (business) i2N (indie)
HOME | FREE NEWS SUBMISSION | PREMIUM PR DISTRIBUTION | PR COPYWRITING | RSS FEEDS | TESTIMONIALS | CONTACT

Sections: Band | Business | Career | Events | Label | Music Releases | Radio | Tech | Video | Web Events
Genres: Country/Folk | Dance/Electronica | Jazz/Blues | Latin | Rock | Urban | World
International: Asia | Canada | Europe

Advertise | Artist Development | Submit Video | MusicDish*China | MusicDish e-Journal | MusicDish Network | Urban Music News Network
Business News (more headlines) 04-07-2013

Cowan Liebowitz Attorneys Obtain Decision Against Second Hand Digital Music Marketer

Bookmark and Share
Cowan, Liebowitz & Latman successfully represented Capitol Records, LLC, the copyright owner of sound recordings by such famous artists as the Beatles, Frank Sinatra, Coldplay and Katy Perry, in establishing copyright infringement against ReDigi, Inc., a start-up technology company that touts itself as "the world's first and only online marketplace for digital used music." Closely watched by the media, bloggers and major players in online digital distribution, the case is one of first impression, addressing for the first time in a U.S. court the applicability of the "first sale doctrine" to digital goods.

"the world's first and only online marketplace for digital used music."
In resolving what it called "a fundamental clash over culture, policy, and copyright law," the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York granted Capitol's motion for partial summary judgment in an order signed on March 30, 2013 and released on April 1, 2013. The Court held that ReDigi's service, which permitted users to sell their legally purchased iTunes digital music files to other ReDigi users, violated Capitol's exclusive reproduction and distribution rights under the copyright law. The Court further ruled that ReDigi was liable as a direct, contributory and vicarious infringer of Capitol's copyrights.

In so holding, the Court found that ReDigi's alleged process of "migrating" digital music files did not technologically avoid "reproduction" of Capitol's sound recordings. Citing the language of the Copyright Act, its legislative history and "the law of physics," Judge Richard Sullivan held that ReDigi "reproduced" Capitol's sound recordings by embodying them on the new "material object" of ReDigi's server, regardless of the purported novelty of ReDigi's system.

The Court likewise held that ReDigi violated Capitol's exclusive right of "distribution" by processing sales of music files. In particular, Judge Sullivan found that the first sale doctrine, which allows the owner of a lawfully made copy of a copyrighted work to dispose of that particular copy, did not apply to the transmission of digital files. Because sales through ReDigi require that the digital music files first be uploaded to the ReDigi site, the process necessarily involves unauthorized reproduction of Capitol's copyrighted sound recordings rather than the "resale" of the "particular" copies of those recordings.

The Court made clear from the outset that it was not inclined to enter the thicket of policy arguments asserted by ReDigi and various interested third parties who unsuccessfully sought to participate as amicus curiae: "Because this is a court of law and not a congressional subcommittee or technology blog, the issues are narrow, technical, and purely legal." At the same time, the Court pointed out that the policy arguments were not "as straightforward or uncontested as ReDigi suggests," noting that the Copyright Office had previously rejected extension of the first sale doctrine to the distribution of digital works because of the aggravated threats to copyright owners in the digital realm. Ultimately, the Court concluded that it was for Congress to determine whether the first sale doctrine required the changes advocated by ReDigi: "the Court cannot of its own accord condone the wholesale application of the first sale defense to the digital sphere, particularly where Congress itself has declined to take that step."

Bookmark and Share

back | top



MusicDish Advertising Network

Mi2N Music PR

Let's Rock This Game! Music Marathon Rocks China

Aminita Satori Releases "Where Language Fails" As Intellectual Stoners Rejoice

"Musicians At Play" Foundation Debuts With First Concert - "The Vintage Masters Of Swing" Headlines The Broad Stage In Santa Monica On June 13th

Chinese Rockers Second Hand Rose To Perform Paleo Festival, One Of Europe's Largest Music Events

ArtistMax To Present Three-Day Artist Development Sessions At LAs Legendary Village Studios

Piece Of The Rack: Eventide H3000 Factory Plug-In $150 Off

IQzic Music Discovery Platform Now Open To All

Eventide Announces H9 Max Spring Giveaway



MusicDish*China Song Blast
Promote Your Music Single In China

News Headlines
Mi2N EDITOR'S PICKS
» IFPI Publishes Digital Music Report 2015
» IConnectivity Releases IConnectAUDIO4+
» UMG And Class Action Attorneys Propose Settlement Agreement On Digital Download Royalties
» CMT Announces Plans To Produce Its First-Ever Music Video For An Artist
» Fair Play Fair Play Act Introduced To Address Musician And Label Compensation
» Outline Names Luca Giaroli Business Development Manager
» Overstock.com Rocks Style With Live Bret Michaels
» The 20th Annual USA Songwriting Competition Accepting Entries
» Through Trials And Tribulations, New York Rock Outfit THE ROYAL GUARD Set To Debut Powerful Sophomore Album
» Canadian Singer/Songwriter Billy Grima Signs With MTS Management Group


Get your music news covered...
Have your press release written
by the pros at Mi2N

Articles
MUSICDISH E-JOURNAL
» INTRO Electronic Music Festival: Interview With DJ Weng Weng
» VUE Audiotechnik Establishes VUE China
» March 28, 2015: A Black Day For Yaogun (Chinese Rock)
» Inside All That Matters: John Cappo, CEO, AEG China
» Inside All That Matters: Shen LiHui, Founder, Modernsky Entertainment
» Rock In Rio Teams With Fanstang To Stream Festival In Mainland China And Integrate Chinese Music Into Future Shows
» Inside All That Matters: Marc Vincent, President, Sennheiser Greater China
» Inside All That Matters: John Cappo, CEO, AEG China
» Inside All That Matters: Shen LiHui, Founder, Modernsky Entertainment
» Inside All That Matters: Marc Vincent, President, Sennheiser Greater China
» ReverbNation And SESAC To Nurture Emerging Artists
» Veteran Chinese Rocker Wu Tong Presents "Song Of The Sheng"

Mi2N's Music PR distribution service guarantees online exposure for your press release. Choose from seven (7) different packages.


HOME | FREE NEWS SUBMISSION | PREMIUM PR DISTRIBUTION | PR COPYWRITING | RSS FEEDS | TESTIMONIALS | CONTACT

Sections: Band | Business | Career | Events | Label | Music Releases | Radio | Tech | Video | Web Events
Genres: Country/Folk | Dance/Electronica | Jazz/Blues | Latin | Rock | Urban | World
International: Asia | Canada | Europe

Advertise | Artist Development | Submit Video | MusicDish*China | MusicDish e-Journal | MusicDish Network | Urban Music News Network
Copyright © 1997-2015 MusicDish LLC, all rights reserved. Text, graphics, and HTML code are protected by US and International Copyright Laws, and may not be copied, reprinted, published, translated, hosted, or otherwise distributed by any means without explicit permission.